In Matthew 6, Jesus teaches the twelve disciples how to pray by offering a beautiful model of prayer now known as the Lord’s Prayer. He says in verses 9 to 13:
This, then, is how you should pray:
“Our Father in heaven,
hallowed be your name,
your kingdom come,
your will be done,
on earth as it is in heaven.
Give us today our daily bread.
And forgive us our debts,
as we also have forgiven our debtors.
And lead us not into temptation,
but deliver us from the evil one.”
He then adds in verses 14 and 15:
For if you forgive other people when they sin against you, your heavenly Father will also forgive you. But if you do not forgive others their sins, your Father will not forgive your sins.
Jesus uses the word for to connect verse 13 to verse 14, where for means “because of this.” Verse 12 is all about forgiveness, presumably making the subject of verse 13’s seemingly ambiguous temptation also about forgiveness. Putting 12 and 13 together with 14 and 15, it is quite possible
Jesus is inviting us to ask God to help us avoid the temptation to not forgive our offenders.
But what is a temptation, exactly? According to James 1:14,
Each person is tempted when they are dragged away by their own evil desire and enticed.
So when we’re tempted not to forgive, it’s because of a natural yet evil desire we must actively oppose. But we can’t fight it in our own power. We need the humility to know we need God! Without him, we can be tempted to refuse to forgive our offender. And that refusal can come out of pride.
But pride is costly. Proverbs 16:18 says,
Pride goes before destruction, a haughty spirit before a fall.
Pride creates complications, hardships, obstacles, and challenges where there may otherwise have been none. When we refuse to forgive, we are telling God, “Look, I know what you said about forgiveness, but I know how to handle this situation better than you do. They owe me. But bitterness is the tax you pay on someone else’s debt of offense.
Financial institutions use contracts to acknowledge when a debt is owed between two parties. A less formal financial agreement is called an IOU, standing for “I owe you.” A financial agreement can take the form of a mortgage, car lease, credit card, or even a note between friends—any agreement where parties acknowledge how much is owed and the terms to repay the debt. And when we are bitter, we often hold an emotional IOU against our offender.
Emotional IOUs are more complicated than financial IOUs. While financial IOUs exist only when both parties agree to the amount owed and terms of repayment, emotional IOUs can exist whether or not both parties agree to it. An emotional IOU can be created when one party feels their values, rights, or expectations were violated, even if the person who violated them refuses
to acknowledge that a debt exists.
Like the father who abandoned your family and tries to reconnect with you years later as if nothing happened. No acknowledgment, no ownership, no remorse, just expectations of warmth. The emotional IOU you hold against him causes you to wait for an apology that never comes.
Or the friend who distanced herself over a minor issue and, instead of working through it, disappeared. Months later, she resurfaces in your messages with a casual, “Hey, stranger,” as if you have been out of touch. The emotional IOU you hold against her causes you to wait for an acknowledgment of wrong that never comes.
Or the significant other who humiliates you at a party, then wrongly quotes Scripture by saying, “The Bible says to forgive and forget” instead of just saying, “I’m sorry.” The emotional IOU you hold against them causes you to wait for some sense of remorse that never comes.
What do you do when someone owes you a debt of repentance but refuses to pay it? Well, I believe your next step depends on what you want to see happen for you. You can’t control what someone else does, but you can control how you respond to what they do based on the outcome you want for yourself.
If you enjoy feeling angry about what they did and like rehearsing how you feel and how much they owe you, the choice is clear: Hang on to their debt—and the torment that comes with it. Think about it as often as possible. Talk to other people about how much your offender owes you. If you are still connected to the person, keep attempting to collect the debt by reminding
them how badly they hurt you.
But if you’ve tried these tactics and are tired of getting the same broken results, may I offer you a second option? Write it off as bad debt.
Peace costs less than payback.